Three whole fish laid nose-out on a thick bed of crushed ice, gills open and eyes clear.

From Around the World And Around the CornerA retail and wholesale fish market in Mastic, New York.

Retail fish at wholesale prices. Fifty years on Mastic Road, open seven days a week.

Two whole silver fish laid on crushed ice, shot close on the head of the front one — clear dark eye, gold-green gill plate, scales still wet.

Retail

Fish by the pound, clams by the dozen. The selection changes daily with the catch. Call ahead and it will be ready when you arrive.

Call Your Order In

Dozens of live lobsters piled together, dark mottled shells flecked with orange, their claws banded shut in green, blue and yellow.

Wholesale

Delivered seven days a week across Suffolk and Nassau. Call your order in the day before and it goes out to your kitchen.

Call for Wholesale

Whole silver fish packed edge to edge across the counter, a chalked price board behind them.

Today at the counter

The Catch

Our selection changes daily based on our catches of the day. Looking for something special? Give us a call and ask. We are always available to help.

Local Fish
Whatever the boats bring in. Whole or filleted to order.
Lobster
Live from the tank, claws banded. Always at a great price.
Clams
Littlenecks, topnecks, cherrystones and chowders, by the dozen or by the bushel.

Call to Place an Order

Fifty years on Mastic Road

Started by Baymen

Over fifty years ago this store was started by local baymen — immigrants who knew the bay, the rivers and the ocean around this community inside and out.

Our experienced team members choose the freshest seafood from around the world and around the corner

A Conveyor Belt, Both Ways

Around one side of the storefront, box trucks and vans pull in to buy wholesale — restaurant owners travelling anywhere from Montauk to Manhattan. On the opposite side, local fishermen pull in to sell off their daily catch. It is a full-circle operation, and it runs all day.

We pride ourselves in not only having the freshest fish around, but also our service and hospitality towards each set of feet that walks in. We know many of our retail and wholesale customers on a first-name basis.

The manager, Mastic Seafood

Source: PJ Balzer, “An Oldie but Goodie”, The Messenger Papers, 14 August 2025

The bow of a small working boat, buoys and coiled rope stowed against a crate of netting.

A working harbour seen from above, boats tied along the finger docks and a yard behind them.

Where the Fish Goes

In the summer months the Instagram fills with high-end chefs picking out fish for dinner parties on Dune Road and across the East End. Fish that sits on a thick bed of ice in a small storefront on Mastic Road ends up at some of the most exclusive tables the East End hosts.

As reported by The Messenger Papers, August 2025.

Westhampton
Southampton
Greenport
Port Jefferson
Patchogue

and many other towns across Suffolk and Nassau.

Fishing boats tied up along the dock on a flat, bright morning.

A round wooden bushel basket packed with live blue crabs, their claws tipped in blue and their shells still wet, a gloved hand steadying one at the near rim.

From the neighbourhood

What People Say

Hands filleting a whole fish on a board at the counter.

This neighborhood fishmonger mainstay is always jammed year-round. I wish I had a local fish market like this by me. They have just about anything you want and at very decent prices.

Danielle B. · Yelp